In what might be one of the stupidest rulings I have ever heard of as it pertains to internet law, a Kentucky judge ruled that 141 domain names be transferred from internet gambling sites to Kentucky officials.
This is completely worthless on so many levels — the US does not own or regulate the internet, let alone Kentucky! Can you imagine if other countries started regulating what was available on the internet and seizing domain names? The idea that a state in the US can regulate a site that has an international audience is beyond absurd.
Also, this will not stop or hinder internet gambling in the least. Gambling sites use programs that you download in order to access their services. These programs do not rely on the domain names that are being seized, but are pointed to IP addresses of specific servers. Seizing the domain names isn’t going to stop anyone from continuing to gambling using software they have already downloaded. At most it will prevent new people from downloading the software for a very short amount of time — until the company puts everything on a new domain name. OK — you seized gambling.com, I’ll put everything on gambling.net, or gambling.cc, or gambling-stuff-here-download-it-now.com.
Judge Wingate demonstrated his complete ignorance of technology when he said that he would be willing to exempt any gambling site that would use “geographically filtering” to block Kentucky residents. It is trivial to use a proxy server in your browser to circumvent any attempt to geographically filter users — Google “proxy servers” and you’ll see how many are out there to use — many for free.
Politicians and lawmakers need to realize that you cannot apply old-school laws and practices to new technology. The internet is a global phenomenon and we can’t regulate how Japan, China, or other international countries utilize it. I think it’s funny how much money and effort China pours into “censoring” the internet. I’m sure that they do a pretty good job of wiping the majority of what they don’t want seen on major sites, but if you think that there aren’t some Chinese computer geeks that know enough about encryption and internet protocols to get to whatever they want to see, you’re kidding yourself.
Information and knowledge was always meant to be free … the internet is making that a reality and will eventually overcome all obstacles that those in power want to put in the way of citizens that just want to live free!